Hiring the Wrong Scrum Master Cripples Teams
Hiring an unqualified Scrum Master limits team growth, reduces agility, and hinders value delivery. Effective Scrum Masters drive change, coaching, …
TL;DR; Hiring a Scrum Master is challenging because many organizations misunderstand the role and focus on the wrong qualifications. A strong Scrum Master needs deep knowledge of Scrum, the ability to drive team effectiveness, and enough technical understanding to support your teams and foster change. Look for candidates who demonstrate commitment, challenge assumptions, and coach teams to deliver real value, not just those with certifications or project management backgrounds.

Hiring a Scrum Master is hard. Not because the role is rare—there are plenty of CVs with “Scrum Master” slapped on them—but because too many organisations still don’t know what they actually need.
A Scrum Master isn’t a project manager with a fancy title. They’re accountable for the effectiveness of the Scrum Team, which means they need a deep understanding of Scrum as a social technology and how it enables adaptive solutions.
Do they need to be technical? Not necessarily, but likely. They need to understand what effective looks like in your business and technical domain. A Scrum Master who can’t speak the language of your teams won’t be much use when it comes to removing impediments, coaching the team, and driving organisational change.
A certification isn’t a guarantee of competence, but it’s a decent starting point. If someone isn’t willing to spend $200 on a PSM I or $250 on a PSM II to validate their knowledge, what does that say about their commitment?
If you want a Scrum Master who makes a difference, stop looking for someone to “run stand-ups” and start looking for someone who challenges assumptions, coaches teams, and ensures delivery of real value.
Hiring? Or struggling to define what a Scrum Master should do?
Each classification [Concepts, Categories, & Tags] was assigned using AI-powered semantic analysis and scored across relevance, depth, and alignment. Final decisions? Still human. Always traceable. Hover to see how it applies.
If you've made it this far, it's worth connecting with our principal consultant and coach, Martin Hinshelwood, for a 30-minute 'ask me anything' call.
We partner with businesses across diverse industries, including finance, insurance, healthcare, pharmaceuticals, technology, engineering, transportation, hospitality, entertainment, legal, government, and military sectors.

Cognizant Microsoft Business Group (MBG)

Workday
NIT A/S

Milliman

Healthgrades

New Signature

SuperControl

ALS Life Sciences

Slicedbread

Flowmaster (a Mentor Graphics Company)

Deliotte

Jack Links

MacDonald Humfrey (Automation) Ltd.

Teleplan
CR2

Illumina

YearUp.org

Brandes Investment Partners L.P.

Nottingham County Council

Department of Work and Pensions (UK)

New Hampshire Supreme Court

Royal Air Force

Washington Department of Enterprise Services

Ghana Police Service

ALS Life Sciences

Microsoft

Workday

Emerson Process Management

Qualco

Slaughter and May