Home > Helpful Resources > Scrum is like communism, it doesn’t work. Myth 2.

Scrum is like communism, it doesn’t work. Myth 2.

Unraveling the Story Point Myth in Scrum: A Path to Clarity 🚀

Hello, Agile practitioners! Today, I’m tackling a pervasive myth that has become a common stumbling block in Scrum teams: the Story Point Conundrum. This myth often manifests as confusion and frustration around the use of story points, with many questioning their value and relevance in Scrum. Let’s dive deep into this myth, understand its origins, and explore how we can navigate beyond it to foster more effective and meaningful Agile practices. 🌟

The Proxy Myth of Story Points in Scrum 🎭

A common narrative I encounter in Scrum circles revolves around the extensive time spent on estimating story points, which measure complexity rather than time, and then trying to fit these points into a sprint. Here’s the catch: Story points are not inherently a part of Scrum. They’ve been adopted as a complementary practice, but they’re not prescribed by Scrum itself.

Understanding Story Points: Beyond the Misconception 🛠️

Story points were conceived as a tool for developers to facilitate discussions around unknowns in a project. The essence of using story points—through practices like planning poker—is not about assigning a numerical value to complexity but about uncovering what the team doesn’t know.

The Apology from the Creator of Story Points 📜

Interestingly, the individual generally credited with inventing story points has publicly apologized for their creation, due to the way they’ve been misapplied within organizations. Instead of serving as a tool for insight, story points have often been used as a quasi-measure of time, leading to undue pressure on developers.

Refining Our Approach to Story Points ✨

The primary utility of story points lies in their ability to facilitate conversations during backlog refinement. They help teams gauge the relative complexity of tasks and identify gaps in understanding. Here’s how we can shift our perspective and practices around story points:

  1. Focus on Conversation, Not Quantification: Use story points as a catalyst for discussion among team members to explore uncertainties and align on understanding.
  2. Keep Context in Mind: Story points should primarily be used during backlog refinement to help right-size backlog items and assess whether they fit within a sprint.
  3. Discard After Use: Once story points have served their purpose in fostering understanding, let them go. They’re not meant to be a persistent measure or a tool for comparison beyond their initial context.

Moving Beyond Story Points: Practical Steps 🚀

If you find that story points are adding more confusion than clarity to your Scrum practice, it’s time to reevaluate their use. Here are steps to navigate away from reliance on story points:

  • Experiment with Alternative Estimation Techniques: Consider methods like T-shirt sizing or even #noestimates to focus on delivering value without the overhead of detailed estimation.
  • Embrace Empirical Process Control: Shift the emphasis from upfront estimation to inspection and adaptation based on actual progress and emerging insights.
  • Cultivate Open Dialogue: Encourage team members to share their perspectives and uncertainties openly, creating a culture where learning and adaptation are valued over adherence to arbitrary metrics.

Conclusion: A Return to Scrum’s Essence 🌈

The story point myth highlights a broader challenge within Agile practices: the tendency to cling to specific tools or metrics at the expense of the underlying principles of empiricism and collaboration. By revisiting the intent behind story points and refocusing on the goals of Scrum, we can foster more resilient, responsive, and effective teams.

Remember, the true measure of success in Scrum isn’t how accurately we estimate complexity but how well we deliver value to our customers through collaborative effort and continuous learning.

If you’ve found this exploration of the story point myth enlightening and wish to delve deeper into Agile, Scrum, or DevOps practices, don’t hesitate to reach out. Let’s continue the conversation over a coffee chat and uncover more ways to enhance our Agile journeys together.