The Tyranny of Taylorism and how to detect Agile BS

TL;DR; Many organizations still use outdated management practices from the industrial era that focus on control and repetition, which do not fit modern software development. Although most teams claim to be agile, very few actually use key agile practices like short iterations, ordered backlogs, or regular retrospectives, mainly because they lack effective feedback loops. Development managers should critically assess whether their teams are truly agile and prioritize building real feedback mechanisms to improve outcomes.

Published on 1 April 2020

Written by Martin Hinshelwood

2 minute read

https://nkdagility.com/resources/IDMjGi5C8lS

Something very close to my heart is helping folks understand the origin of the practices that are commonly used in management today. I feel that only with an understanding of history can we figure out how to change the future. I often talk about this in my classes and help folks see why things are the way that they are in many organisations.

We are still using workplace practices developed during the industrial revolution to manage factory workers and the mechanisation of those workers. When we had to build at scale but did not have the technology to build robots, it was down to humans to do this monotonous, repetitive work; Think factory floor or typing pool. These practices, envisioned by Frederic Winston Taylor to control workers, are the Tyranny of Taylorism that we battle every day in our working environments.

While 81% of all development shops say that they are adopting agile, the reality is far from it; only 22% do short iterations, 16% have ordered backlogs, & 13% do retrospectives!

They still lack feedback loops.

Feedback loops were not significant when our current management practices were developed. We had defigned work, we understood it very well, and we were optimising a production line.

Those days are gone now!

https://youtu.be/FZeT8O5Ucwg

View Presentation: https://nkdagility.net/30MVagF

DIB Guide: Detecting Agile BS: https://nkdagility.net/DOD-Detecting

Connect with Martin Hinshelwood

If you've made it this far, it's worth a conversation. Tell us where you are and what you're trying to change. Martin reads every inquiry and replies personally.

Start the conversation

Our Happy Clients

We partner with businesses across diverse industries, including finance, insurance, healthcare, pharmaceuticals, technology, engineering, transportation, hospitality, entertainment, legal, government, and military sectors.