The Role of Agency in Scrum
Explains why true Scrum requires real team agency, not just self-management in name, and how lacking agency leads to ineffective, ritualistic Agile …
TL;DR; Agile transformations often fail because they focus on following ceremonies instead of building real agency in people and systems. True agility comes from empowering individuals and teams to make decisions and adapt, supported by evidence-based management to measure outcomes and guide change. To succeed, shift your transformation efforts from compliance to fostering agency and use data to drive continuous improvement.
Most agile transformations fail not because they get the ceremonies wrong, but because they misunderstand the real point: cultivating agency in people and systems.
You can install all the stand-ups, backlogs, retrospectives, and planning sessions you want. Without genuine agency, you’re not transforming. You’re decorating.
Agentic Agility is the bridge between doing Agile and being agile. It reconnects the mechanical adoption of frameworks with the deeper need for autonomy, purpose, and empirical adaptability. Without agency, agility remains performative theatre. With agency, it becomes adaptive strength.
Most transformations stall because they focus on ceremonial compliance:
Meanwhile, decision latency remains high, impediments are tolerated, and delivery remains brittle. The system stays paralysed by learned helplessness.
Transformation is about a shift in beliefs and constraints, not just behaviours:
This is the ethos behind Agentic Agility: fostering human agency (the ability to act with intention) and system agency (the capacity for the system itself to adapt).
When we focus transformation efforts solely on compliance and ceremony, we institutionalise fragility. When we focus on agency, we unleash resilience.
You cannot manage what you cannot measure. You cannot empower what you cannot observe.
This is why I have consistently pointed to Evidence-Based Management (EBM) as a cornerstone for real change. EBM gives organisations the tools to:
Without an evidence-based feedback loop, agency collapses into chaos or bureaucratic decay. EBM operationalises Agentic Agility by aligning action with impact.
Transformations without agency are short-lived. Transformations without evidence are blind. Transformations with neither are inevitable failures.
Agentic Agility reframes transformation away from ceremonies and towards capacity:
The next evolution of agility will not be led by those who install more frameworks. It will be led by those who build organisations capable of thinking, learning, and acting for themselves.
Agentic Agility is not an option. It is the missing lever for real change.
Each classification [Concepts, Categories, & Tags] was assigned using AI-powered semantic analysis and scored across relevance, depth, and alignment. Final decisions? Still human. Always traceable. Hover to see how it applies.
If you've made it this far, it's worth connecting with our principal consultant and coach, Martin Hinshelwood, for a 30-minute 'ask me anything' call.
We partner with businesses across diverse industries, including finance, insurance, healthcare, pharmaceuticals, technology, engineering, transportation, hospitality, entertainment, legal, government, and military sectors.
Lockheed Martin
Healthgrades
Philips
Graham & Brown
SuperControl
Milliman
Teleplan
Xceptor - Process and Data Automation
Illumina
New Signature
Lean SA
Flowmaster (a Mentor Graphics Company)
Deliotte
DFDS
Sage
YearUp.org
Hubtel Ghana
Slicedbread
Department of Work and Pensions (UK)
Ghana Police Service
Washington Department of Enterprise Services
Nottingham County Council
Washington Department of Transport
Royal Air Force
New Signature
Boxit Document Solutions
Schlumberger
Qualco
Teleplan
Graham & Brown